Photo Discussion
Category: Constructive Critique

To discuss a photo, sign up as a BetterPhoto member or log in.

 

Morning in Black and White


 

BetterPhoto.com Editor's Pick  
MORNING IN BLACK AND WHITE
MORNING IN BLACK AND WHITE

Debbie E. Payne

 
 
 

Debbie E. Payne
 

Another black and white challenge entry. Taken as soon as the sun was shining in the house.


To love this question, log in above
October 15, 2012

 

Dale Hardin
  I like this Debbie for it's composition and tonal quality.

Would be interested to see it with a bit more contrast though. There is not a feeling of sunlight because the shadows are so soft. You might consider burning the shadows, especially under the bowl, on the table, the couch, and the salt/pepper shakers, etc.

Then increase the overall brightness by about 10%. (soften highlights if this creates a problem)


To love this comment, log in above
October 15, 2012

 
- Michael Kelly

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Michael Kelly
Michael Kelly's Gallery
  Just wonderful B&W tones and the glossy reflections on the S&P and fruit are wonderful. Not sure what Dale is after here but I like it as shown. I think it has a richness and warmth to it that is hard to accomplish in B&W


To love this comment, log in above
October 15, 2012

 

Debbra Bailey
  I love your composition! So simple, yet it tells a little bit of a story about you. I like the tones too.


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 

Debbie E. Payne
  Debbra - I didn't think of the storytelling aspect at first but you are right. Like the books in the background, the large picture window nearly the whole length of the family room and the sunglasses ready to go and how I like fruit. It did not come across well in color. Too much artificial light in the kitchen, making it too yellow to my taste, although I could certainly have worked on color balance if I had wanted to.

Dale, I may come back and look at a bit more contrast but I kind of like it as is as well. I am not looking for drama here. It is just a quiet kind of scene about my house in the morning. Hopefully, you will be sitting around this table one day in the not too distant future.

PS -- Anyone else is welcome too!


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 
- Rita K. Connell

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Rita K. Connell
Rita K. Connell's Gallery
  great shot and very well edited. have you gotten all moved. we need to talk, I will see how friday goes.


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 

Jeff E Jensen
  I like it. Very well done!


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 

Debbie E. Payne
  Rita -- Have you forgotten, or didn't I tell you that LAST MINUTE I decided that it was the wrong thing to do? Even Martin agreed. If I hadn't said anything, we'd be moved and I probably would have mourned this house we are currently in and plan to stay, for now, at least. Now, if I were to win the lottery and could afford a nearly $600,000 house, yes: I'd move in a heartbeat. But we never win anything so that is not a viable option. My little neighborhood is a lovely place to be and we are just "sprucing" this one up so that if something perfect presents itself we will be ready to sell.


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 

Beth Spencer
  Debbie, I like this shot! I think the composition does work and it looks so nice and clean!! Think of all the trouble you saved yourself staying! The big thing is that you are happy!


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 

Stephen Shoff
  Debbie, I really like the composition and scene it sets -- a comfortable, inviting dining area where you'd be really comfortable sitting down and enjoying a piece of fruit.

for me, I think it is a little over-sharpened for that. And it isn't clear how the sunglasses fit into that setting. The seem a little discordant to me.

I like your concept of a low drama mood so I'm not sure higher contrast/structure is necessary, but as Dale mentioned, there isn't a sense of "sunlight" in this image. It may just need a little brightening.


To love this comment, log in above
October 16, 2012

 
simplydivinephotography.com - Susan M. Reynolds

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Susan M. Reynolds
Susan M. Reynolds's Gallery
  I noticed the storytelling or photojournal aspect of the photo at a glance. Love the books in the BG & perhaps a comfy chair there to curl up in for a good evening's read...all my books are still packed away in the garage Boo!
I think all the different textures also make it interesting, from the fruit to the wood grain, the placematand furniture fading into the BG. I can understand that the sunglasses represent you by being placed in easy reach so you're ready to go at the drop of a hat.
I, too, think it looks good as is, but could also be more dramatic with the contrast of darker shadows under the bowl and the one cast from the chair onto the table. Nicel done for the B&W challenge :)


To love this comment, log in above
October 17, 2012

 
Log in or sign up to respond or interact.