youth was the first casualty

© Matthew Roybal

youth was the first casualty

Bernard B. Travers 5/14/2003 10:40:48 PM

This is really very well conceived. Excellent job, Matthew. #35019

Matthew Roybal

Thank you Bernard! Well you know the wall is like a reflection into the past. Of lost buddies or memories, or youth. My father like most veterans feels an emotional conection with this memorial(probably the most well designed of all the war memorials in my opinion). And the black granite is a perfect mirror into each mans indivdual experiance. #96898

Juliane Morris-Lusk

What a narrative photo essay...This is wondeful, and teaches the youth in the present moment. Five years ago, this photo would talk to many, now it speaks to many, many more. Thank you. And great creation. #96984

Sally A. Rothweiler

This is really wonderful, the image and writing! Your pop must be proud of you. You certainly are proud of him! Way to go, Matthew! #96999

Damian P. Gadal

Very powerful image! #97022

Carl D. Miller

Great composite Mat! This definitely says a lot! Did you get your father to pose with the same expression, that adds a lot to this. This seems pretty well thought out. I like the three layer effect with the recent photo right up front and then the older shot farther back and then the wall. Youth left behind and even farther their dead friends. Great job! #97156

Matthew Roybal

Thank you all! I am very proud of my father, he sacrificed a lot. This is a technique thats very easy to do, I like to think of it as ghosting. create a layer, adjust lluminosity to about 40% add a slight glow, then shoot your pic with the space you are going to use for the ghost "in mind". #97265

Matthew Roybal

Oh and Carl, no my father chose that pose naturally. Ironic uh. And it actually was only 2 layers, he was standing in front of the wall. ( Posted anything lately Carl?) #97322

Patrick Campbell

Congrats and good luck in the finals Matthew. I barely missed being drafted for this war. Seeing the Vietnam Memorial in person is a powerful experience. #113718

Matthew Roybal

Thank you Patrick, I am glad you missed the action over there, from what I hear it wasnt fun. #114877

Bernard B. Travers

Great photo - great choice for finalist. Congrats, Matthew. #114919

Kathleen Clemons

Congratulations on your win with this very powerful image! #117062

Peggy Wolff

Congrats on your win! THis is such an interesting photo. #117290

Connie I. Chandler

Congratulations! What a poignant idea for a photograph! Well deserved win! #117381

Patrick Campbell

Congrats Matthew--glad to see the judges also appreciated the excellence of this image. #117498

Bernard B. Travers

I knew this one had it. Congratulations, Matthew. #117504

Carl D. Miller

Way to go Dude! I had a hunch this would be winner. #117516

Matthew Roybal

Thanks guys! When I thought up this image I didnt relize the response it would get. I knew the feeling of this photo, when I was young my dad would tell me stories from "Nam". That feeling....the look in my fathers eye when he talked about his "KIA" freinds, or the sniper attacks, or what its like landing in a "hot LZ" from a huey helicopter....that feeling you can only get talking to a veteran. That was what I was trying to convey. Thanks everyone! #117880

Connie L. Carpenter

What an awesome idea... it is the first time I have viewed this image and I have to say that it made me cry... unbelievably powerful... and your words harken back my father's stories as well. This is beautiful... beautiful... wish I could steal it but my father is gone. Congratulations.. it is so very well deserved. #117915

Matthew Roybal

Thank you Connie! my condolances about your dad....Im sure he was a special guy. I appreciate his service to our country.

And if anyone wants to steal this idea for a Vietnam vet ...DO IT. I have even taken old pictures of men that died over there, and used this technique with a living relative. Almost like the spirit of the dead soldier has come to the Wall to meet with thier loved one. like a gateway between the living and the dead. It really is a mirror, or portal, or passageway. Use the power of Photoshop to bring this passageway to life! #118006

Wolfgang Dolak

Oh, boy. This is great. Sorry I missed it. But even if a little late - big congrats on this tell-tale image of yours. It really deserves to be here!!
birdie #118233

Gary H. Minish

A powerful story and a powerful photo that captures the emotion of it. Very well thought out and created, Matthew! A very well deserved win. Congratulations! #118671

Dolores Neilson

What an emotional piece, Matthew! A loving tribute to the many who sacrificed more than we can imagine. Your father is a have gone in the trenches of hell to give to his country and survived is heroism. What a beautiful, moving, poignant piece! Congratulations! #119637

Matthew Roybal

Thanks Wolfgang, Gary, Dolores, Im very excited about this win. All of you are important members of this commmunity. Without feedback, and communication this community wouldnt be as healthy as it is.

Wolfgang? What does birdie mean? Is it some sort of "parting words"?
European? #120319

Aaron Werther

well matt, this is a very engaging photo. And it looks like you could place a beer on top of your father's head. #124704

Cathy M. Gromball

Congratulations, Matthew!

Cathy :) #126385

To discuss, first log in or sign up (buttons are at top center of page).


A pic of my father at the moving wall, combined with a pic of my dad at Ke sahn combined in photoshop.

Uploaded on 5/14/2003 7:47:29 PM All Time Best Photo Contest Editor's Pick Photo Contest SECOND PLACE Winner

Copyright for this gallery photo belongs solely to Matthew Roybal. Images may not be copied, downloaded, or used in any way without the expressed, written permission of the photographer.
Log in to follow or message this photographer or report this photo.