BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: All About Photography : Photographic Field Techniques : Studio, Still, & Personal Portraiture Photography

Photography Question 
Rachel Larson
BetterPhoto Member Since: 12/3/2005
 

Combining Color Temperatures


I am going to be purchasing additional lighting. I currently have two soft boxes that are continuous, tungsten, 2800K. Would it be a problem if the new lighting is either 3200K, or 5600K? And what is the suggested white balance to shoot on?
Thanks for your time!


To love this question, log in above
11/11/2008 5:59:03 PM

 
John H. Siskin
BetterPhoto Member
John-Siskin.com
John's Photo Courses:
4-Week Short Course: An Introduction to Photographic Lighting
4-Week Short Course: Getting Started in Commercial Photography
4-Week Short Course: Portrait Photography Lighting on Location and in the Studio
  Hi Rachel,
A 3200 light source would be visibly cooler than your soft boxes, but I can't tell you that the difference would bother you. If you were doing critical color work - such as photographing artwork - this difference would be unacceptable. A 5600 light source, like a strobe, would be a real problem for any usage that combined your soft boxes and the bluer light source. I would use a tungsten preset balance with your soft boxes, or do a custom white balance.
Thanks, John Siskin


To love this comment, log in above
11/11/2008 9:39:19 PM

 
Alan N. Marcus   Hi Rachel,

The color of the output of lamps, especially photo lamps, is customarily measured using a temperature scale proposed by the British scientist Lord Kelvin. This scale has appeal as it starts at absolute zero, the coldest possible. Thus the Kelvin scale never used negative numbers. This avoids the possibility of confusing ten below with ten above. The Kelvin scale starts at 273 Celsius and calls this low temperature zero. For this reason the Kelvin scale is also called the Absolute scale.

Now the metallurgy industry took to this scale. Steel making was centered in Sheffield and they had great respect for Lord Kelvin. Anyway, heated iron glows red-hot. Continue to heat and its color changes eventually reaching blue-white hot. The temperature of the metal corresponds to the color of its light output. Ordinary electric lamps used metal filaments. The metal, usually tungsten, is heated as electric power surges through it. The filament temperature is what we are talking about.

Ordinary electric bulbs = 2800K
These are designed to operate at a specific voltage. In the U.S. this is 120V in Europe 220V. If you apply more than the design voltage the lamp gets much hotter, brighter, and more bluish however, the life of the lamp is severely shortened.

Photographers, in their studios and the movie industry, routinely over-volted to get more light. Two arrangements evolved one delivered 3200K the other 3400K. As higher voltage is applied the temperature goes up, the lamp gets brighter, its life shortens, the light shifts towards the blue. Soon lamps were made for both applications. Film was also marketed, labeled Tungsten Type B for 3200K and Tungsten Type A for 3400K. We carried a gadget bag of conversion filters so we could be ready for anything.

Electronic flash replicates daylight 5500K. Daylight is not constant; at dawn and sunset it is quite ruddy, close to ordinary electric bulbs. North skylight is 6000K. Modern digitals have automatic white balance, chip logic that measures and adjusts for shifting hues of light. Additionally you can manually set your digital for a specific type of light. Color temperature measurements fail for florescent lamps and most gaseous discharge lamps. However, temperatures are routinely assigned these lamps, often the value is invalid because these sources produce light that has an interpreted spectrum.

How about mixing and matching?
Photography is both an art and a science. You are free to mix for imaginative reasons. The logic in the digital camera cant handle and correct for mismatches. You should strive to keep your lighting uniform. Electronic flash is preferred for a variety of reasons; this is just one of them.

If you are forced to mix and match, you can buy colored filters for your lights. Filters are installed over the lamps to alter their color. This method has merit but is costly and requires some exterminating.

The bottom line is: Better to buy lamps that are uniform in color output.

Alan Marcus (marginal technical gobbledygook)
alanmaxiemarcus@att.net


To love this comment, log in above
11/12/2008 8:38:21 AM

 
Pete H
BetterPhoto Member Since: 8/9/2005
  Rachel,

Mixing light sources is generally a no-no.

Manually balancing a camera will give you an average of ALL the tempertures.

The real problem that arises is positional. You may have your mains at 2,800K and the fill at 3,200. You will almost certainly see a color discrepency from shadow to light.

A 2,800K main and 5,600K fill would be very noticable.

Other than special effects, I know of no one who mixes color temp with their lights.

Pete


To love this comment, log in above
11/12/2008 3:07:40 PM

 
Log in to respond or ask your own question.