Photo Discussion

Sort most recent comments first

To discuss a photo, sign up as a BetterPhoto member or log in.

Moonset

  Moonset
Moonset
The full moon setting on the Pacific at sunrise. Taken from the balcony of our motel room. Nikon N90, Nikon 70-210 zoom. Elitechrome 100.
© Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
 
 
 
Ronnie Smith     Hi, Shirley. I'm from Toronto, Canada. I like this shot a lot.


To love this question, log in above
11/2/2001 7:13:35 PM

 
Glenn Theal  

Hi, Shirley,

I too like this shot. However, I find the moon to be too bright and too sharp when compared to the rest of the image. It just doesn't seem to fit quite right.

I would like to see the image without the moon, or I would like to see it with the moon fogged or blurred and some of the contrast/brightness removed.

Cheers,
Glenn


To love this comment, log in above
11/2/2001 11:23:52 PM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you both. Glenn, this is the way the moon looked... there has been no digital manipulation, other than resizing for this venue. Remember, the full moon sets at the same time the sun rises and the moon is reflecting the light of the sun.


To love this comment, log in above
11/3/2001 8:24:57 PM

 
Guy D. Biechele
BetterPhoto Member Since: 7/15/2000
Contact Guy
Guy's Gallery
 

FANTASTIC!! The range of blues, the textures in the surf, and the wisps of clouds across the moon. What a reward for an early riser! (With your skill). +Guy


To love this comment, log in above
11/3/2001 11:37:07 PM

 
Jaap Zuidersma  

Shirley,

What strikes me about this picture is the continuance of the wave patern in the clouds that drift in front of the moon. It's almost as if the big wave in front and some of the smaler ones in the back are reflected on the moon. About the sharpness af the moon, well nature presents itself in its own way.

I wonder what you can do whith a late night shot (smile).


To love this comment, log in above
11/4/2001 10:21:59 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you Guy and Jaap, for your enthusiastic comments.


To love this comment, log in above
11/4/2001 3:50:53 PM

 
Laura Johnson  

B E A U T I F U L !!!!


To love this comment, log in above
11/7/2001 7:17:28 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you so very much, Laura.


To love this comment, log in above
11/7/2001 4:53:40 PM

 
Brian Wiehn  

I really like this shot. I also like the way the moon is sharp it balances out the texture of waves at the bottom of the shot. Again a fantastic shot.


To love this comment, log in above
11/10/2001 12:23:46 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you very much, Brian.


To love this comment, log in above
11/10/2001 2:12:57 AM

 
Chuck   

What was it Laura said ? oh yes.

B E A U T I F U L !!!!

D I T T O, D I T T O, D I T T O !

Chuck


To love this comment, log in above
11/14/2001 11:13:01 AM

 
Sue B  

First of all, I'd be proud to have taken this photograph. Secondly, I see there are different opinions about the moon; I have to agree with Glenn that the moon tries to take over the picture and distracts from those beautiful waves. I know you said that was how the moon looked, with no digital manipulation, so here's my question. Did it look like that "in person" or could it have brightened up with the camera's exposure? I think it's a wonderful photo, but esp in the larger view of the picture, I blocked out the moon with my hand to see the waves better. (This "discussion" is mostly for my own sake - how to expose the moon to keep it muted - can it be done?)


To love this comment, log in above
11/25/2001 10:08:20 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Hi Sue. Yes, it would be possible to artificially mute the moon, perhaps with a graduated neutral density filter, but why would you want to? The moon is the SUBJECT of the photo. If I wanted only the wave patterns, that is what I would have taken. The bright, golden, setting moon is what makes this photo special. If you were taking a sunset, would you want to MUTE the sun...not really, you might want to even your exposure. so that the foreground does not black out. However, this photo has a perfectly exposed foreground, so that is not a problem here.

Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
11/25/2001 5:37:32 PM

 
Ronnie Smith  

Hi again Shirley. I'm Ronnie from Toronto, Canada. Your first response - your 100% right. Don't touch it - looks beautiful, it adds contrast, my dear.


To love this comment, log in above
11/25/2001 6:31:49 PM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you, Ronnie!


To love this comment, log in above
11/25/2001 6:39:22 PM

 
Sue B  

Hi Shirley - Thanks for the idea of using a graduated filter! They say that art is subjective; possibly my reaction to your photo came from living where I do. I see the moon all the time, and never get to see waves! Also had an insight when you asked if I would want to mute the sun in a picture of a sunset, and my response was "yes, probably" as I would be more interested in the lighting in the surrounding clouds. My question wasn't meant to insult your picture - like I said, I'd be proud to have taken it. I was just wanting to learn more about how to achieve different effects with different exposures.


To love this comment, log in above
11/26/2001 8:09:01 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you, Sue... I'm not insulted.


To love this comment, log in above
11/26/2001 6:50:53 PM

 
Charisse Baldoria  

I do like this photo very much to the point that it's been my computer wallpaper for about a month now. I think it's perfectly lovely; to me, the moonshine is a pleasant unexpected accent. it may be brighter than the rest and may nudge your sense of balance a little bit; but like other unexpected gestures, like in Beethoven's music, for example, it jars you a little bit and makes the artwork more interesting. the treatment of this little element just completely changes the meaning of the entire work, compared to if it had not been thus treated. if there were no such moonlight and only smooth waves, the picture will have a different character altogether--maybe lacking in tension, in my opinion.


To love this comment, log in above
12/10/2001 10:54:33 PM

 
Crystal Sadler  

Very nice!
Bravo Zulu!
CRYSTAL SADLER


To love this comment, log in above
12/11/2001 12:45:10 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you so much, Charisse. Such wonderful compliments! And thank you, Crystal!
Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
12/11/2001 4:35:00 PM

 
David D  

Hi Shirley,
This is one of the greatest picture as I see at this site. Did you try shot as Horizontal format at that time. If you did, how does it look? I feel that it might looks better.
Over all it is a perfect picture.
David


To love this comment, log in above
12/11/2001 9:57:00 PM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you, David. Yes, I did several shots of this, both vertical and horizontal. As the moon went down, it began to look like a UFO.

Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
12/13/2001 1:19:54 AM

 
Marie   

Hi Shirley, I think your photo is outstanding. I am brand new to 35mm photography and hope to be able to take some photos of this calibre soon.
Marie


To love this comment, log in above
12/13/2001 7:20:28 PM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you, Marie.

Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
12/13/2001 8:24:47 PM

 
David D  

Hi Shirley,
It's me, David D again.
That is not too good, Moon become a UFO! The reason I was interesting in a horizontal format is that it must have more spaces for the ocean part. Since you took the exposure reading by the Moon, (as I saw from your pic.) In a horizontal format picture, a part of image would be darker, while another part of picture where the wart directly under the Moon would be brighter. And may be you got some Moon light refection there. So it would have more contrast and more texture. Well, here I am assuming that in the horizontal picture you would put the Moon at the corner of the picture, instead of at the center.
Accidentally, today I just saw your another picture, which is a portrait of a woman in the blue lights. I looked photographer's name, It was your name again! It seems to me that your works are very outstanding at this web site, as far as I concern. (By the way, I only visited this web site twice. But twice, your pictures made my eyes stop there. Great Job!!!)


To love this comment, log in above
12/15/2001 2:49:18 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Hi David, nice to hear from you again, and Thank you! Actually, in my horizontal photos, I try NOT to center the moon...it is much more interesting off-center. And by the time the moon has set this low, you cannot see a light trail on the water, and the faint sunlight from the rising sun (which shows on the waves) counters the moonlight. When the is higher, and before the sun comes up, you can see the light trail. Also, it makes no difference in the exposure whether the photo is vertical or horizontal, because I meter what is best for the entire photo.


To love this comment, log in above
12/15/2001 5:01:42 PM

 
David D  

Hi Shirley,
It is interesting to talk you, and glad to hear from you.
I think we have a similar thought about the horizontal format image in terms of composition. AS I said í░I am assuming you would put the Moon at the CORNER of the image, INSTEAD OF at the centerí▒. Too bad it did not work out. I doní»t photograph landscape picture very much. (Almost 5 years from now, I havení»t shot any landscape). But when I did at that time, I prefer use horizontal format or square format. For only one reason ---- MARKETING. And vertical or square formats for portrait most of time. (Most of my portraits are studio work). As a piece of artwork I like to use square format for the image. It makes the image look much more elegant. Well, this is my personal preference only.
David D


To love this comment, log in above
12/16/2001 12:14:14 PM

 
Geoffrey T. Wallace  

Hi Shirley:

I think the moon makes the picture much stronger. I too tried cropping it out with my hands and the picture loses a lot of its interest that way. Its a wonderful image.


To love this comment, log in above
12/17/2001 6:29:49 PM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you, Geoff.
Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
12/18/2001 12:16:32 AM

 
Janett Gomez  

What a beautiful picture! All I can say is it takes my breath away...


To love this comment, log in above
1/16/2002 3:21:13 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you very much, Janett!

Shirley


To love this comment, log in above
1/16/2002 5:18:15 PM

 
Dee Wooten  

WOW! That moon just pops out of that picture with all of those beautiful blue hues surrounding it. I LOVE IT!! That's incredible!


To love this comment, log in above

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Thank you very much, Dee!


To love this comment, log in above

 
Dee Basinger  

I wouldn't change a thing. It's a fantastic photo, worthy of gallery consideration.


To love this comment, log in above
1/4/2004 7:25:04 AM

 
Dee Wooten  

One more thing...If I were standing on that beach at the same time you took the picture, it's the moon I would be gazing at. Of course you want to capture on film what captures your eye. If we all saw things the same way, we wouldn't have such a beautiful variety of pictures to share with others. I enjoy them all, but some really captivate me as yours did.


To love this comment, log in above
1/4/2004 9:26:16 AM

 
Shirley D. Cross-Taylor
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/7/2001
Contact Shirley
Shirley's Gallery
 

Wow. Thank you so very much, Dee.


To love this comment, log in above
1/4/2004 3:24:58 PM

 
Log in or sign up to respond | Contest | Gallery | Discussions