Photo Discussion
Category: Constructive Critique

To discuss a photo, sign up as a BetterPhoto member or log in.

 

Rule 7


 
  Redo foreground objects give depth
Redo foreground objects give depth
Versailles, Paris. 1/150 at f/8.0, ISO 200, 52mm
Building color made warmer.

Karen N. Guertin

 
 
 
- Roxie Guilhamet

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Roxie Guilhamet
Roxie Guilhamet's Gallery
 

This scene shows well how foreground objects give depth. First, you use the interplay between foreground and background, the most important thing. You have a scene to draw us in, the palace of Versailles. Then, you have something of interest in the immediate foreground—the statue of cherubs. The palace itself would be flat without them.

You've increased the sense of depth by including the whole line of statues decreasing in size into the distance. The varying sizes of the people adds even more depth. This is because we know people are basically the same height, so when their size changes this much, our brains see the third dimension to explain the difference. Great example here!

The cherubs are in focus, as they need to be. And their size and and placement is good for the overall composition. The color contrast of green against orange makes them stand out as well.

Good job remembering to use side light for depth. And the color of the light is lovely. As Rob Sheppard suggested, you could even warm up the building more to bring out the warmth of the afternoon sun.

Wide angle lenses show off this technique the best, so I'm glad you used it here. It looks like the building is bowed a bit from your wide angle lens, though, and slightly skewed—easy to do when shooting a building straight-on. The Adaptive Wide-Angle Filter in Photoshop CS6 will easily fix this. Draw in verticals on both sides and horizontals across the building at the top and along the white balcony. That should align things properly.


To love this question, log in above
June 29, 2012

 
- Roxie Guilhamet

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Roxie Guilhamet
Roxie Guilhamet's Gallery
  Yes, this second version brings out the warmth of the afternoon sun on the building, giving the image that much more punch. Nice. The building's lines better too. Thanks for redoing it.


To love this comment, log in above
August 02, 2012

 
Log in or sign up to respond or interact.