Alvin C. Lopinot |
How to judge photos in competition DOES ANYONE KNOW OF A JUDGING CHECK LIST THAT CAN BE USED BY SEVERAL JUDGES IN RANKING THE BEST PHOTOS IN COMPETITION. I HAVE CONTACED SEVERAL ORGANIZATIONS CONCERNNG THIS AND NONE HAVE AN ANSWER. THANKS ALVIN LOPINOT
|
|
|
||
John A. Lind |
Alvin, No need to "shout" . . . you can use lowercase letters. :-) My take on this (an opinion), and it's something I've contemplated on several occasions . . . Presentation: Technical Execution: Visual Interest: Message and Intent: -- John
|
|
|
||
Tony Sweet |
Judging is subjective, Alvin. Even with the well layed out categories that John mentioned, the bottom line is all judges evaluate images through their own personal prism, experience, and personal visual prejudices. The most important judge is YOU. The only person you have to please is you. The only person who has to live with your image is you. Judges only have one opinion, but not the ultimate opinion. That's yours. The most important thing is to have fun!
|
|
|
||
Alvin C. Lopinot |
It is right to be subjective in judging a photo contest if only one person is doing it. How about when three or five are doing it? It would be more fair to the photographer in the contest if all the judges were on the same wavelength. Surely there must be some standards that all judges look for. Alvin Lopinot
|
|
|
||
Tony Sweet |
These are for slide competition. Print competitions are different and involve printing techniques and other technical criteria. Universal design concepts standards: And, of course, none of these may apply if the judge is incompetent (it has been know to happen!) Tony Sweet
|
|
|
||
- Gregory LaGrange Contact Gregory LaGrange Gregory LaGrange's Gallery |
A good picture dosen't have to follow rules either. Because you can have a good picture with the subject right in the middle of the frame, regardless of the rule of thirds.
|
|
|
||
- GARY L. ROHRBAUGH Contact GARY L. ROHRBAUGH GARY L. ROHRBAUGH's Gallery |
I have to agree with Tony's first response! "Judging is subjective" Yes the first point is you have to like your photo, then hope you get feedback to help you craft you hobby if it's in a positive or negative way. Gary Rohrbaugh
|
|
|
||
- Gregory LaGrange Contact Gregory LaGrange Gregory LaGrange's Gallery |
Very subjective. A picture of a chicken won first place.
|
|
|
||
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here
Report this Thread |