BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: New Answers

Photography Question 

Murray G. A
 

Eliminating black coners of photos


After buying a 2nd hand Pentax SFX I ran 2 rolls of film through it - Konica ASA 100 and Fuji ASA 400. The majority of photos were taken on overcast days. Two issues have cropped up.

1) On both films (although the 2nd Fuji the issue was not as numerous) some of the photos had black 'rounding' in the corners (usually the rt-hand side) as if somehow on that side the curvature of the inside of the lens barrel was intruding in the photo.

2)With shutter speeds selected automatically by the camera, the Fuji film has come out noticeably darker and colours less intense than the Konica (which was, for most (but not all) photos darker than I would have liked), although both times the camera correctly identified the film speed and should have adjusted accordingly. Should next time I tell the camera that the film is of a slower speed to convince it to take slower shutter speeds? I bough this camera so I had a film camera that could work competantly on auto to complement my fully manual one, so would prefer it if it was possible to keep the fully auto features. I am guessing that it may be a camera fault as with the same Fuji ASA400 films I have taken fantastic photos with a Minolta X-300 and my wife has with a Minolta Dynax 300.

Thanks


To love this question, log in above
March 07, 2008

 

Debby A. Tabb
  It would be nice if you could post that example here.
But let me ask you this,were you using a lens hood during this shoot?
sounds simple but I see it all the time.


To love this comment, log in above
March 07, 2008

 

Alan N. Marcus
  Hi Murray,

In this post I will address only the black corners. A camera lens projects a circular image that is much larger than the frame mask. The mask I am taking about is the black rectangle, at the rear of camera, it is a baffle that molds the frame dimensions. All lenses produce an image that has reduced light energy at he edges, this corner darkening is called a vignette. On slide film the vignette effect is lighter edges at the corners. Generally a vignette is not noticeable except when shooting using tremendously wide angle lenses. Furthermore, when observed the vignette is seen at all four corners.

So, what would cause a vignette on just one side?
a. It is present on all four corners but the subject matter is mundane where noticed. The other corners have the vignette but it is concealed by busy stuff of the vista.
b. The camera body or lens or mount has been damaged. The camera’s optical system is not centered or the lens is slightly angled in relationship to the camera body.
c. The projected image light rays from the camera lens is obstructed by internal camera parts or a lens hood which is too small or mounted out-of-square.
d. Nothing is wrong with the camera or the lens or the optical path. The film was negative material and you are viewing prints made at a local lab. The photofinishing printer was operated using the wrong lens, it was too short in focal length, this condition yields a visible vignette. The printer’s optical and/or lamphouse system is not precisely centered. These are common sources of a vignette. Carefully inspect your negatives or slides for vignette to rule out the camera and in the photofinisher.
e. When prints are made from slides at a local lab, the probability of a lab induced vignette is high. The camera lens vignettes as does the printer lens. When making prints from negatives the two optical systems produce vignettes that are exact opposites and likely cancel each other. When making prints from slides the camera lens vignette and the printer lens vignette are additive exaggerating the vignette.

More marginal technical gobbledygook from-
Alan Marcus
ammarcus@earthlink.net


To love this comment, log in above
March 07, 2008

 

Alan N. Marcus
  Some points clarified from above: When a camera lens vignettes the edges of the image display reduced light energy. Negative films reveal this vignette with reduced density at the edges (four corners) of the film. Prints made from negative films, both color and black & white have darker edges. A well designed photofinishing projection printer somewhat counters the camera’s vignette when negatives are printed on conventional printing papers.

Slide film displays a vignette dark at the edges and in severe cases the corners appear somewhat rounded. Prints made from slides are more likely to show a vignette; both the printer lens and the camera lens compound the problem and maybe the printer lamphouse will be a contributor.


To love this comment, log in above
March 07, 2008

 

Murray G. A
 
 
 
Thanks for the responses.

Looking at the photos again, of the ones with the black corners a few also have the same thing on the left (but nowhere near as pronounced or intrusive as the right. I've attached a photo of one of the photos taken (sorry, ny scanner does not want to work at the moment) so you can see the exact effect.

To answer a previous question, yes I was using a 49mm lens hood that came with the camera.

Thanks


To love this comment, log in above
March 07, 2008

 

Murray G. A
 
 
  Photo of black-cornered photo
Photo of black-cornered photo
Photo of black-cornered photo

Murray G. A

 
 
Thanks for the responses.

Looking at the photos again, of the ones with the black corners a few also have the same thing on the left (but nowhere near as pronounced or intrusive as the right. I've attached a photo of one of the photos taken (sorry, ny scanner does not want to work at the moment) so you can see the exact effect.

To answer a previous question, yes I was using a 49mm lens hood that came with the camera.

Thanks


To love this comment, log in above
March 08, 2008

 
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here

Report this Thread