BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: New Answers

Jessica A. Eiss

I wanted to share these pics with you


	Shed Brook Falls 1 Jessica A. Eiss
	Shed Brook Falls 2 Jessica A. Eiss
	Shed Brook Falls 3 Jessica A. Eiss

I know this isn'[t the right forum, but the critique doesn't seem to be either.

This little gorge is very peaceful, and I am very happy with how the veiling turned out. Jess

To love this question, log in above
August 30, 2006

Kerry L. Walker

Beautiful pictures, Jessica.

To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2006

Jessica A. Eiss

thanks Kerry. Jess

To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2006

Irene Troy

Hi Jessica - you sound a little frustrated! Let me guess, you wanted a real critique and only got "Wow, nice image!". Of-course, it is always nice to hear from people who like our images, but I know I always appreciate it when someone points out faults and how I can improve, or at least tells me why they like an image.

So, on this note and taking liberty that you did not ask for (Maybe you did!): your images are very nice and overall I like your composition. However, the light is really not great for shooting this type image. I find that waterfalls, particularly those in somewhat open areas (these appear to fit that description) often photograph better on overcast/cloudy days or when the light is more muted. The greens are greener and the water can often have wonderful reflections. Of-course, you may want to use a polarizer to prevent the reflection from being too great. Anyway, thats my bare 2 cents in the for-what -it's- worth department!

Good shooting and have fun!

Irene

To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2006

Tim Goodspeed

Jessica, I would echo Irene's comments. However, these images do not appear to have been shot on a bright sunny day at noon. The bit of sky showing on #2 looks overcast. So I think the issue is the time of day you shot these. Try for the early morning or late evening hours. Study other winning waterfall images of past BP Photo Contests. You will see that light plays an important part in most all of them.

To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2006

Jessica A. Eiss

Thanks Irene and Tim. No actually you're reading me wrong. It's not about me, it's about some pics being so-so, and others being very nice, but not getting any recognition or response. If a pic is being posted in the critique section, then 25-101 replys shouldn't be about how great a pic is, and there not be any c.c. If people get bent out of shape about being publicly critiqued, then they shouldn't post there. I think it's frustrating for new people to ask for advice, and not get any. It's more like a popularity contest. JMO!!!!

About my pictures, I really posted them, because I like them, and just wanted to share. I already received private email with some suggestions, and that was wonderful. As I replied to him, I don't have thin skin, and I know I am not a GREAT photographer, but want to improve.

The pics were actually taken on an overcast evening, between 6:30-7pm'ish.
On the bright double falls, I realized I left a +EV dialed in, and that's why it's brighter. I know not to shoot falls in bright sunlight, and purposely
chose an overcast eve. I do need a polarizer though, and that will be a purchase I make soon.

I guess I could have boosted the saturation in PSE3, but didn't think it needed it. Maybe it did? Thanks for your responses and looking. I just wanted to vent too, as a fairly new-comer! Jess

To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2006

Kerry L. Walker

Oh, the pitfalls of having an uncalibrated monitor. Since my monitor is not calibrated properly, photos seem darker than they really are so they look great to me. Apparently, to others, they seem a little too bright. I would just tone them down a bit. The veiling is done well and the composition looks good to me. I wouldn't use a polarizer in an instance like this because you want (or at least I would) to get those reflections.