BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: Holidays & Special Event Photography

Photography Question 

Frank P. Luongo
 

Photographing Trees with Holiday Lights


At night when shooting photos of trees decorated with lights (all white), how should one accomplish this? F/22 with slow shutter speed? Wider aperture, say f/5.6 with faster shutter speed?
Where do you meter from - one of the lights itself?
Do you open up a stop? Etc.
Thanks.


To love this question, log in above
December 03, 2004

 

Bob Cammarata
  Use a tungsten-balanced film (or proper filtration), and meter off the lights. Your aperture setting will depend upon how much DOF the scene requires.
Keep in mind that a smaller aperture (f-22) will create little starbursts off each light source. You should consider this if you want that effect to show when choosing your f-stop.
It's always wise to bracket these types of exposures to get just what you want.


To love this comment, log in above
December 03, 2004

 

Frank P. Luongo
  Thanks, Bob. I appreciate it.


To love this comment, log in above
December 03, 2004

 

Steve Warren
  Hi,

This is kind of a question for Bob ... By metering off of the lights, won't the scene underexpose? I mean, if it's a high-contrast scene such as a lighted tree at night, wouldn't the meter read the lights as a mid-tone rather than the bright part of a high-contrast scene and treat them as such??


To love this comment, log in above
December 06, 2004

 

Bob Cammarata
  Steve,
You are correct, but this type of exposure usually calls for multi-second exposure times ... which doesn't always "play well" with some films.
My advice should have recommended metering off the lights to get a starting point, and to bracket OVER from there. Thanks for pointing this out.
Bob


To love this comment, log in above
December 06, 2004

 

David Robinson
  Take an integrated reading of the whole scene.
Take a spot reading off the filament of one of the lights
Under-expose from the spot reading by one stop.
Compare this new reading (ie. the minus one stop exposure) with the integrated reading to ensure that the scene will not be hopelessly underexposed. If ok then use the minus one stop reading for your exposure.


To love this comment, log in above
December 07, 2004

 

David Robinson
  Take an integrated reading of the whole scene.
Take a spot reading off the filament of one of the lights
Under-expose from the spot reading by one stop.
Compare this new reading (ie. the minus one stop exposure) with the integrated reading to ensure that the scene will not be hopelessly underexposed. If ok then use the minus one stop reading for your exposure.


To love this comment, log in above
December 07, 2004

 

David Robinson
  Take an integrated reading of the whole scene.
Take a spot reading off the filament of one of the lights
Under-expose from the spot reading by one stop.
Compare this new reading (ie. the minus one stop exposure) with the integrated reading to ensure that the scene will not be hopelessly underexposed. If ok then use the minus one stop reading for your exposure.


To love this comment, log in above
December 07, 2004

 

Kristen
  This isn't really about exposure, but just a side note...if you use a 6x filter when shooting Christmas lights, it creates cool stars from the lights and has an awesome effect.


To love this comment, log in above
December 07, 2004

 

David Robinson
  Take an integrated reading of the whole scene.
Take a spot reading off the filament of one of the lights
Under-expose from the spot reading by one stop.
Compare this new reading (ie. the minus one stop exposure) with the integrated reading to ensure that the scene will not be hopelessly underexposed. If ok then use the minus one stop reading for your exposure.


To love this comment, log in above
December 07, 2004

 

Frank P. Luongo
  Thank You All for your suggestions!
How about a street lined by rows of lit trees, in which you want some detail in the shadows,AND you want to stop down to f/22 to get starburst effect?
How would your metering strategy change?

Thanks


To love this comment, log in above
December 09, 2004

 
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here

Report this Thread