Photo Discussion
Category: Constructive Critique

To discuss a photo, sign up as a BetterPhoto member or log in.

 

bodnath


 
  bodnath
bodnath

lisa anderson

 
 
 
- Michael Kelly

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Michael Kelly
Michael Kelly's Gallery
 

Love the bird silhouettes in this. Tones look good though I might lighten the shadows a touch. I think I would also crop just a bit off the right side so the partial roof is eliminated. Even a clone in that area might work or a combination of a slight crop and clone.


To love this question, log in above
October 14, 2012

 

Stephen Shoff
  Or you might use the distortion tool instead, and experiment with pulling out the upper right corner more than the left. Using the distortion tool would reduce the curvature which I'm guessing is something you want to retain, and is certainly a pleasing component of this scene, but not by a lot. It would additionally help straighten the verticals at the bottom center of the frame.

Very nice capture with great tonalities and dramatic sky.


To love this comment, log in above
October 14, 2012

 

Jeff E Jensen
  Your B&W conversion works really well, Lisa. I agree on the crop/distortion suggestions from Stephen and Mike. I think either way will help.


To love this comment, log in above
October 14, 2012

 

Dale Hardin
  Very interesting scene Lisa. Love the birds and the sky.

As mentioned, it's obvious you want to emphisize the spherical look of this lens, so instead of distorting the image to lessen that effect, use the tool to enhance the effect.

Pull the upper left corner up untill the lines attatched to the peak of the temple are horizontal. This will also lift that entire side to better match the right. The pull the lower left corner untill the items in the lower center of the image have vertical lines that are straight.

Finally, open the shadows a bit but mask the sky so it stays the same.


To love this comment, log in above
October 14, 2012

 

Aimee C. Eisaman
  A very powerful image esp. with the contrast of the birds to the sky...love that! As for the distorting and all that just give it a try...I have no idea what the guys are really talking about so I guess when you try it I'll see. lol I do agree about opening the shadows, but not in the sky. Right now I keep searching the bottom of the image for more detail in the faces and just can't get my eyes back to those awesome birds. I think with more detail I will be able to let my eye wonder more. :~) Also a 1 pixel stroke around the whole image will help it not to blend into the BP background on the top.


To love this comment, log in above
October 14, 2012

 

Elaine Hessler
  What an interesting picture! I love the view-distortion and all. The birds fill up the sky nicely to add interest. Very cool!


To love this comment, log in above
October 14, 2012

 
simplydivinephotography.com - Susan M. Reynolds

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Susan M. Reynolds
Susan M. Reynolds's Gallery
  The detail in the cloudy sky with the addition all of those birds on top of the fisheye lens look of the photo, makes it both dramatic & appealing. I'd like to see Dale's suggestions, if you plan on editing :)


To love this comment, log in above
October 17, 2012

 

Debbie E. Payne
  Lisa -- I like this shot. The birds do add and mirror the element of motion in this shot which isn't always easy to convey. I would only bring out some detail in the shadows and am interested in seeing this image made even more skewed.


To love this comment, log in above
October 18, 2012

 

lisa anderson
 
 
  bodnath edit attempt
bodnath edit attempt

lisa anderson

 
 
Ok, I used a layer mask for the first time, so that's exciting (although I maybe went overboard with opening the shadows). I also tried using the distortion tool, but could only get the photo to alternate between fun house horror mirror distortions and barely changed. Practice practice practice...


To love this comment, log in above
October 19, 2012

 
Log in or sign up to respond or interact.