The battle

© Protacio Serna

The battle

Uploaded: March 23, 2005

Description

Focal Length: 200mm
White Balance: Shade
Exposure Mode: Manual
AF Mode: AF-C
Metering Mode: Multi-Pattern
1/400 sec - f/2.8
Exposure Comp.: 0 EV


Comments

Protacio Serna March 23, 2005

Other than cropping the head (which was intentional) I'll appreciate any other comments about the image.

Regards
PSerna.com

#228184

Kate Jackson March 23, 2005

I love the way you've focused on the (matador? with his impressive outfit. It's a great picture, Protacio but, being an English softee, I am worried what happened to the bull?!! #1201278

Mellanie March 23, 2005

fantastic composition and color, protacio! #1201453

Susana Ms Heide March 23, 2005

This is the most artistic image I have ever seen of this bullfighting sport! #1201548

Susana Ms Heide March 23, 2005

This is the most artistic image I have ever seen of this sport! #1201550

Protacio Serna March 24, 2005

Thank you all for your comments.

In close ups I always try to focus on the bullfighter. The depth of field is shallow and since the bulls are dark it is better to get details from the matador.

This is the beginning of the bullfight and the bull hasn’t been punished yet. I try to get the most images possible from this part of the fight but unfortunately it is too short.

About what happened to the bull, that’s another story. I got that picture as well…I’m not sure what to do with it.

Regards
http://www.pserna.com
#1203387

Melissa L. Zavadil March 24, 2005

I love the way that you divided the picture into three distinct triangular sections (matador, cape, bull). The bull rushing the cape almost gives the viewer a pinwheel effect. The cropping of the picture is absolutely perfect for the reasons I stated above (of course you would crop the head) good job!. The only thing that is throwing my eye off just slightly is the clashing of the two different reds, but I don't know if that is what is attracting me to this picture. Let me think about this for a minite.......
OK, it almost seems like the wall needs to be a yellowish green color (or) the cape needs to be a blueish-green color but of course this does not make sence based on the content of the picture. The picture is absolutely great as is but I am curious what it might look like with complementary colors.

I guess there is another way to look at this photo, all the colors on the right are warm colors where as the pink-purple cape is vibrant attracting your eye to the cape. AHH that might be it, if that is the theory then you might lighten the red wall around the cape.
Ok, sorry for thinking outloud on this one but it has intrigued me!
GREAT PICTURE!
the bull charging the cape. #1203738

Melissa L. Zavadil March 24, 2005

Ok, If you are not opposed to photoshop try this picture with a jeweled green toned wall. I think you might like the results!
Melissa #1203767

Stan Kwasniowski March 24, 2005

Protacia, I like your image, as for the head in my opinion not required, you have the bull, dust, matador's outfit the horns going for the cape, and you filled the frame, Beautiful

Stan Kwasniowski #1203777

Protacio Serna March 24, 2005

Hi Stan...thanks for your comment. I’m glad you liked it.

Melissa. Thank you for the time and for sharing your thoughts about this image.

As for replacing the color of the wall behind I got something to confess: I just did…but I knew I wouldn’t like it. There are a couple of reasons why and the most important reason is that the wall must be red. It is part of the tradition of bullfighting.

Why the wall is painted red? I don’t know. I know the cape must be red to mislead the bull hiding the body of the bullfighter and perhaps by blending with the red background.

I’m not sure about why it should be painted red, but when I’m photographing at the bullring, I zoom at the red wall and adjust the exposure accordingly. Nothing beats this red for a perfect exposure.

Thanks again.
Protacio

#1204369

Melissa L. Zavadil March 24, 2005

Well thanks for having an open mind. I guess that is where you need to understand the subject matter also! :) Thanks for the information on bullfighting. #1204561

Shane Nestle March 24, 2005

Excellent sharpness, color, saturation. It took me a bit of staring to realize what I was looking at. The bull is so completely black, I didn't realize it was an intergal part of the picture at first. Instead, my attention was drawn to the upper body, but I still could not figure out what I was looking at. My first thought was this was a macro. I can understand taking out the face, but maybe a little of the shoulder and neckline or collar would help the image to be readily clear. Of course, I'm tired so, it could just be that. It's a great shot over all. #1204598

Dorothy Neumann March 24, 2005

I'm not going to get into a debate about the strengths and weaknesses of this image...obviously there are many people more sophisticated than I am about the nuances of such things. However, I think you should know that bulls are color-blind, and the bull would charge the cape no matter its color...it's the movement of the cape and not the color that raises his ire! #1204616

Protacio Serna March 24, 2005

Thanks Shane for your message. I agree with you about the shoulders.

You are 100% right Dorothy. Bulls are color blind. The cape is waved in front of him and it also works as a decoy.

Thanks
PSerna.com #1204633

Pam M March 25, 2005

as a stand alone pic ... I have to agree I felt a little disoriented as to what I was looking at. ... BUT oh WOW .. in the proper setting or with a grouping of other bullfight photos ... where the mind is already thinking "bullfight!" ... WOW !!!

Just as I was trying to think this through ... my daughter interrupted my field of vision with an IM (The Girl who had to move across country to get her BS in Graphic Design) And we had the following discussion about your photo.

Daughter: i'm going

Pam: ok have fun

Pam: WAIT look fast [link to your photo]

Pam: some are saying he should stick some of the matador back on but I don't think so

Daughter: No no no..

Pam: but it's soooo balanced on the right and center and plus the bull is sooo beautiful

Daughter: the matador makes a great color/texture pattern

Daughter: you can tell what this is but I don't think that's the point of the photo. it looks like an abstract with color and motion and patterns and then you get to figure out what's really going on

Daughter: why does everything have to be readily clear these days?! it's annoying

Pam: yeah ... can you imagine this pic in a bullfight museum ...

Pam: can you just see this in a book or collection of other fight pics

Pam: it would be the ultimate exclaimation point in the group

Daughter: def in a collection!

Daughter: Ok I’m leaving

Pam: Ok, have fun

Daughter: especially if he puts the face back it will completely change the photo because people always look at faces first

Pam: I think the face would be in pain anyway ;-)

Daughter: probably - at least not very attractive

Daughter: OK really ... I’m leaving ! LOL

She said some other stuff ... the short version is: "THis is Great!" Sometimes she puts her stuff up in the HOW Forum (for graphics people) and so now she thinks I'm going to put my pics up here ... where does she get these ideas?! #1206754

Protacio Serna March 26, 2005

WOW.

This is one of the things that never cease to amaze me about modern life. You are somewhere in the States, your daughter in a different time zone, and you were talking about a picture I took last Sunday somewhere south of the border.

Thanks for sharing your conversation with us. It meant a lot to me.

Best regards
Protacio
#1208189


To discuss, first log in or sign up (buttons are at top center of page).

Get Constructive Critiques

Sign up for an interactive online photography course to get critiques on your photos.


 

Did You Know?

Discussions by Category: You can view photo discussions on various themes in the Community > Photo Discussions section of the site.

BetterPhoto Websites: If you see an orange website link directly under the photographer's name, it's totally okay. It's not spam. The reason: BetterPhoto is the one that offers these personal photography websites. We are supporting our clients with those links.

Unavailable EXIF: If there is no other information but 'Unavailable' in the EXIF (meaning no EXIF data exists with the photo), the 'Unavailable' blurb is not displayed. If there is any info, it shows. Many photos have the EXIF stripped out when people modify the image and resave it, before uploading.


 

The following truth is one of the core philosophies of BetterPhoto:

I hear, I forget.
I see, I remember.
I do, I understand.

You learn by doing. Take your next online photography class.


BetterPhoto.com Editor's Pick


Copyright for this photo belongs solely to Protacio Serna.
Images may not be copied, downloaded, or used in any way without the expressed, written permission of the photographer.
Log in to follow or message this photographer or report this photo.