BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: Problems with Images

Photography Question 

Rosie M. Proctor
 

Magnifying lenses


I have always taken pictures, yet now choosing my shots. I was told that because I like close ups so well, that a magnifying lense would make not only my subject as I like it but also would make any thing in front of or behind subject in focus as long as I stand the correct distance away. Is this correct? I have a minolta x-370 slr. Thanks for any comments or help with getting quality shots. Rosie


To love this question, log in above
May 04, 2004

 

Peter K. Burian
  Rosie: Most serious photographers buy a Macro lens that allows for extremely close focusing - for filling the frame with a tiny object such as a large coin or a blossom.

You can find accessories (resembling a filter with magnifying glass) that will achieve the same thing but not with equally high quality. Check out the Nikon 5T and 6T accessories. (Do a search on www.google.com)

Note: In any extreme close focusing work, only the focused subject will be sharp. The foreground and background are blurred, a nice effect. This is not the effect that you want, but it's a fact of life in close focusing even at f/22. (Shallow depth of field.)

Perhaps you are thinking of a filter that's split: one half includes a magnifier and the other half is clear glass. (Magnifies only the foreground.) I have not seen one of those in many years; the effect they produce does not look natural to my eye.

Perhaps I'm not sure exactly how close you mean when you say close-ups. A head and shoulders portrait can be a close-up. I'm assuming you mean closer than that, filling the frame with a blossom, for example.

Cheers! Peter Burian


To love this comment, log in above
May 04, 2004

 

Rosie M. Proctor
  Dear Peter. Yes thank you that helps. I had a lady here in my town at a art show look at some of my photos and this was what she told me. To get a magnifying lense because my close ups were blurry behind and in front of subject. This is why I put up the question because I thought I was doing it correct. We all have different views and I was just getting a few more ideas. Could you look at my pictures and tell me what you think? Thanks so much. Rosie Proctor


To love this comment, log in above
May 04, 2004

 

Peter K. Burian
  Rosie: Some very nice work in your gallery.

I assume we are discussing the nature close-ups. No, there is not filter or lens that will allow you to take such photos and make the foreground and background sharper.

You can try this. Mount camera on a tripod. Set f/22 on the lens. (This will cause the camera to set a long shutter speed; that's why you need a sturdy tripod and need to wait until the wind is not blowing. Otherwise, your pictures will be blurred by camera or subject movement.)

At f/22, more of the foreground and background will appear to be in focus.

Cheers! Peter Burian


To love this comment, log in above
May 05, 2004

 

Rosie M. Proctor
  Thank you Peter for all you inout. I believe I will stay with the way I am doing it. I think they are fine ... Thank You Rosie


To love this comment, log in above
May 05, 2004

 

Peter K. Burian
  Rosie: Do try the f/22 and a tripod sometime when it's not windy, for nature close-up photography.

That may achieve what you want. But I don't see any need for you to buy any accessories.

Cheers! Peter Burian


To love this comment, log in above
May 05, 2004

 

Rosie M. Proctor
  Thanks again Peter. I will try this and when I do I will post my results. Thanks for all your help. Sincerly Rosie


To love this comment, log in above
May 05, 2004

 

Mary Helwagen
  I think that if you used a camera with higher resolution, didn't zoom in as tightly, and then cropped the photo you might get a bit more sharpness in the foreground and background, but then I don't know why you would want to. Isn't the purpose to emphasize the main subject of your photo? If so, then sharper fore and background would de-emphasize your subject.


To love this comment, log in above
May 17, 2004

 
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here

Report this Thread