Photo Discussion

Sort most recent comments first

To discuss a photo, sign up as a BetterPhoto member or log in.

The Quirang

BetterPhoto.com Photo Contest SECOND PLACE Winner
 
The Quirang II
The Quirang II
F10, 1/125s, Sigma EXDG 28-70mm @28mm, ISO 100, Shot in RAW.
Location: Isle of Skye, Scotland.
Date: 15/4/05 approx 2:30pm.
Converted to TIFF and tweaked curves and levels a little.
Used Channel mixer in PS8 boosting Red Ch 35%, Green Ch 10% and
knocking back Blue Ch 8% to achieve a slightly infra-red effect.
I then cloned out a few 'Wooly-backed Haggis' in the lower right
area as these appeared as 'dust specks on a neg'.
The Quirang is a complex series of basalt crags and stacks towards the northern end of the Trotternish Ridge on the Isle of Skye. The Eastern Slope of which is an ancient and massive landslip (20 miles long). At its southern end is the more famous stack The Old Man of Storr.

© Grant Campbell
Canon EOS 20D Digi...
 
 
 
Grant Campbell
BetterPhoto Member Since: 11/5/2004
    Feel free to deconstruct my efforts and give your opinion on artistic or technical points.
Also I'd like to know which composition/crop works best for you of the two examples of 'The Quirang'.
Cheerz
Grant


To love this question, log in above
6/5/2005 12:38:39 AM

 
Bill Goss
BetterPhoto Member Since: 5/7/2005
 

Grant,
I personally don't like B&W much. I'd be interested in seeing a colour version of these images.
I think that there's too much going on in the picture - no clear set of lines. The B&W format leaves you without anything specific to focus on.


To love this comment, log in above
6/5/2005 3:02:56 AM

 
Terry  R. Hatfield
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/4/2003
Contact Terry
Terry 's Gallery
 

Hi Grant Im Not Much For B&W Images Either,This One Has Nice Comp And Tonal Range And That Dramitic Sky Looks Great!The Other Image Lacks Impact This Ones Holds Your Attention Much Better,Great Job:-)


To love this comment, log in above
6/5/2005 4:55:28 AM

 
Pam M
BetterPhoto Member Since: 3/24/2005
 

Okay Grant ... If I tell you why I suspect this one works and the other one doesn't, can we see the color one?
;)

It seems that those of us who read from left to right read photographs in the same way. This image makes strong statements on the left intro to the photo ... the other doesn't.

In this image, the topology is very clearly understood throughout the whole image. The other one looks like cloud shadows made their own imprints and it's difficult to separate depth from shadow.

This image ends on the right with a very clear understanding of depth and subject. The other one is muddled (again I think it's clouds).

Also, in the other image, the so so entry on the left combined with the muddled exit on the right combines to effectively put the subject totally within the "frame" of the pic. The brain is therefore satisfied that that's all there is and is not intrigued to wonder anything more about the image ... thus the loss of attention.

ok so ... now ... stop teasing this flatlander and let me see the color ... please :-D

have fun,
pam


To love this comment, log in above
6/6/2005 4:00:20 PM

 
Bill Goss
BetterPhoto Member Since: 5/7/2005
 

I had another look at the two photos, after reading Pam's comments. I like this one a lot more because it has an interesting item in the foreground (LHS), nice open space in the middle whic acts like a road leading to the to a sharp contrast against the sky. The RHS has balacing shapes in shadow with a long distance view. I said balancing, because it adds a panoramic element without detracting from the focus of the picture which is on the left 2/3rds.

Pam's point about reading photos L-to-R is insteresting. In this case it also coincides with the use of foreground for grounding (I can't think of a better term just now), which is a common technique. See Ronnie E. Howard's picture as an example.

So, having sat and looked at this photo a lot longer, I'm revising my opinion - I'm allowed to do that!. I like it.

Can't say the same for the other one. The focus is in the centre, but there's nothing compelling to keep my attention there. The lighting goes from bright in the foreground to dark at tha back, but there's nothing holding my attention in the large, light LHS area.

I'm glad I saw your photos. Thanks for asking for input as it's made me think more carefully about what I like/dislike. Hopefully I'll learn to apply these principles to my photography.
Critiquing is a double-edged sword!

Cheers,
Bill


To love this comment, log in above
6/6/2005 5:09:08 PM

 
Rosemary Buffoni  

Very interesting discussion going on. I like this one the best-it has good compositional flow thru the image caused by the diagonal flow from strong forground thru the curved center into the lighter (than the other) sky. I feel as if this image goes on forever-whereas the other ends abruptly for me. The tones are also great in this one.
Ro


To love this comment, log in above
6/6/2005 6:50:48 PM

 
Grant Campbell
BetterPhoto Member Since: 11/5/2004
 

 
  The Quirang III
The Quirang III
Thnx for your comments
© Grant Campbell
Canon EOS 20D Digi...
 
Ok, Ok, I give in!!! lol
I really didn't want to submit the original, because it just doesn't do the location any justice and at the time of capture I was concentrating on form, composition, texture and light play (blah blah). So you could say I was thinking in mono, and I'm sure you'll agree that the colour version doesn't come close to the mono version in terms of atmosphere or wonderment at how this landscape was formed. In short it (the mono image) actually draws the viewer to examine the scene more closely. I think it's got something to do with the brain having to 'fill the gaps' that makes mono such an itriguing medium.
On the subject of comparing the two versions in mono, I was torn between these two but I do agree that this one works best. Foregound interest, rules of thirds and sevenths are at play here as well as leading the eye from left to right. However the other version does have some redeeming points, the leading line of the foreground cliff edge forces the viewer (well me, and other weirdo 'right brainers'anyway) to read the image in a circular manner, starting from bottom right and going clockwise, what lets it down though is the lack of human interest eg. I wish I'd put the camera on a self timer and stood at the edge of the abyss! Now that would have made it more compelling. Apologies for the delay in my response, by the way, my college year just wrapped up, so I've been rather busy printing, mounting and helping set up the annual show.


To love this comment, log in above
6/7/2005 12:14:03 PM

 
Bill Goss
BetterPhoto Member Since: 5/7/2005
 

Thank you grant for giving in to the barrage of requests. I have to admit that the B&W is a lot more dramatic than the colour version and is far moodier - it has this dark, brooding feeling about it.


To love this comment, log in above
6/8/2005 6:35:55 AM

 
Pam M
BetterPhoto Member Since: 3/24/2005
 

ok well ya'll can sit and admire the mono alllll you want to ...I'm going to admire the color one. i've gone from why the heck would I wanna be there? to can I please come visit?

See you know what the place looks like. I don't. I find the mono to be harsh, barren and very an upealing. I thought I was looking at a desert land! I don't know how in the world you could have done to have changed that.

Yeah, do that ... go back and stand in the pic ... I am getting a better idea of depth with the color ... but yeah a person in the pic would help ... (there, now you have an "excuse" to go back)


To love this comment, log in above
6/8/2005 12:44:57 PM

 
Grant Campbell
BetterPhoto Member Since: 11/5/2004
 

Oh well, you know what they say: "You can please most of the people most of the time, but you can't please all the people all the time!"
I still prefer the mono pic tho :0)
I will return to Skye at some point, but not for a while, it is one of the most fascinating places in Scotland for the landscape photographer. I've got a load of other shots to sift through from this trip, I'm about to upload another in mo', and few more (some will be in colour to keep everybody pleased) will appear here over the next week or two. Once again thank you all for your appreciation. Grant


To love this comment, log in above
6/8/2005 1:25:40 PM

 
Doug K. Herrman
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/10/2005
 

and for a totally different view...my eye feels the rock in the lower left is out of place here: 1) it is highly contrasty, while the rest of the image is mellow mids. Because of the high visual nature of the rock, it is dominating the image. 2) the right side has an soft, etheral feel, like a moonscape - but the rock is very real and quite hard. I would crop the rock out. Great shot, Grant and I envy you for being in such an exotic place.


To love this comment, log in above
6/9/2005 11:10:56 PM

 
kerby lee pfrangle
BetterPhoto Member Since: 4/19/2005
Contact kerby
kerby's Gallery
pfrangle.com
 

Grant

Congratulations on your second place win.

Job well done and beautiful image.

KErby


To love this comment, log in above
7/25/2005 3:30:29 AM

 
KHAWLA Haddad
BetterPhoto Member Since: 1/23/2005
Contact KHAWLA
KHAWLA's Gallery
 

Congratulations on this beautiful winner!!!


To love this comment, log in above
7/25/2005 8:10:42 AM

 
Ken Grooms
BetterPhoto Member Since: 6/23/2005
 

I dream of taking a picture loke this! Congratulations!


To love this comment, log in above
7/25/2005 2:55:44 PM

 
Sharon  Day
BetterPhoto Member Since: 6/27/2004
Contact Sharon
Sharon 's Gallery
 

Fantastic image, Grant!!! Big congratulations!


To love this comment, log in above
7/25/2005 5:00:19 PM

 
Log in or sign up to respond | Contest | Gallery | Discussions