BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: New Answers

Photography Question 

John Rhodes
 

EV for flash


I often shoot under incandescent lights with the SB-800 on the D200. I use the orange gel color gel filter to match the ambient lighting. I also use the Nikon diffusion dome.
My question: I think I should adjust the EV for about a plus one (+1) to compensate for the gel and dome. What is the difference between adjusting the EV on-camera or adjusting the SB-800 flash for an EV of +1? I have experimented with both and don't see a significant difference in the histograms.

Thanks
John


To love this question, log in above
August 30, 2007

 

Pete H
  John,

Ev is EV no matter how you look at it.

+1 be it flash or Aperture or shutter are the same exposure. Period.
Obviously if the subject is out of the effective EV of your flash, you no longer can count it.

This is NOT to say the same (effect) is attained. (i.e) Depth of field and Freeze or blur.

Raising flash power is only one way of course to adjust exposure.

So; +1 flash with +1 on camera = +2

There are of course limits in what you can and can not do. Ex: +1 w/ flash and +2 with camera when shooting aperture priority might freeze your subject and also may cause a blurred background if you drop too low in shutter speed.

So; yes...Using gels on the flash with a diffusion dome will require some + compensation in (manual) and aperture modes. In (program) mode it will make no difference as the camera has taken control of aperture, shutter,flash quench and power output in a attempt to make a balanced exposure. The "effective" EV of the flash is of course reduced.

I rarely use Program anything with a camera..You see the info on speed and aperture, but you can do nothing about it. Sure you can dial in a + or -...but what did the camera do?..Raise or lower speed, aperture, or both? That's why it's called program..It has been "programmed" with specific speed/aperture defaults to give what it (thinks) will be a balanced exposure. The D-70's manual has a graph on HOW it selects speed/aperture.

The best way to actually measure the amount of standard compensation would be to use a flash meter in manual mode..with and without the gel and diffuser.

Hope this helps a little.

Pete


To love this comment, log in above
August 30, 2007

 

John Rhodes
  Thanks Pete, you have affirmed my thoughts. I shoot in Manual 99% or the time and Aperture priority the rest. I appreciate your response.
John


To love this comment, log in above
August 31, 2007

 
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here

Report this Thread