Dean Bertoncelj |
|
Find a cuts game...
|
|
task
Dean Bertoncelj |
|
|
I saw few similar things here so let me post one picture... task is simple : from how many pictures is this put together ? where are the cuts ?I put numbers on girls to make easyer your answers :o) anyone care to try?
February 22, 2006
|
|
Kerby Pfrangle |
|
Dean this is awesome. I love the youth and beauty in this image. Very nice job of putting this together. I love to learn this to make something like this of my model. Kerby
February 22, 2006
|
|
Kerby Pfrangle |
|
I was relooking at this and my guess is five cuts. But it could be four.
February 22, 2006
|
|
Jon Close |
|
Got some time to kill and willing to be wrong. :-) 1 looks like it could be a single photo, but if you told me her legs came from another image, I'd believe it. (2)2 looks like a composite of at least 3 images (Head + neck and shirt + skirt). 3 I'd guess 3 images (replaced hair, mouth doesn't look right to me). 4 and 5 look like the same model but with one mirror reversed. The bottom of the red top has a light halo. It wouldn't surprise me if the faces are composites. 3 images each. 6 Head + top + pants = 3 7 and 8 are separate images. I think 7's had a head replaced. 8's right arm appears twice: once up with her thumb touching her chin, and also reach down behind 7. Call it 4. So I'll go with 21.
February 22, 2006
|
|
Forrest C. Wilkinson |
|
I think Jon has it a lot closer than what I would have guessed, but I believe you're mistaken on 7 and 8, 8's right arm appears only once, up behind 7's hair, the "other" right I arm you see is 7's right arm bent 90 degrees at the arm and resting on her rear.
February 22, 2006
|
|
Justin G. |
|
#1 has the main about 45 degrees to the right and #2 is flat lighting and there is no shadow one #1 so #1 and #2 are separate. #3 has main light from the left (nose shadow) and her left handis soft but #4's hand is sharp so those are separate.#4 and #5 have the same lighting and 4's shirt causes a shadow on 5 so those are the same image. #6 has frontal lighting and her right arm at the elbow is soft and #5 at the same area is sharp so #6 is separated. At first I thought #7 and #8 was a composite but I believe they are one. 8's hand has a shadow from 7's hair and lighting for 7 & 8 is coming from left with pretty strong fill leaving little shadows on 8. Also the shadow on 8's leg is equivilant to them holding hands so I believe they are together. Also #8 where it looks like she has to arms. I believe the one held up is 8's and the other is 7 creating a window with her hand on her hip towards her butt. In conclusion: #1 - its own #2 - its own #3 - its own #4 & #5 - together #6 - its own #7 & #8 - together. did I get it right?
February 22, 2006
|
|
Dean Bertoncelj |
|
Justin is closest... you are right except one thing ... JonC way too much complicated whole thing, but came up with one basic guess, one girl actually have horizontal cut :o)..conclusion : Justin guess is right with add that girl no2 is made from 2 pictures head and body is one and skirt is second girl 4 and 5 are twins pictured together and that horizontal cut was trap :o)) I posted this before on some forum and noone there go for horizontal cuts :o))
February 22, 2006
|
|
Justin G. |
|
Ahh Dean I was thinking that with the skin tone differences between her face and her hand but threw away the idea. lol. this is a cool game, you should do more Dean! And also you've got some great PS skills, I've seen a lot of your other work on the Sig and wow, great great stuff. you should teach a class or seminar on lighting and PP! lol
February 22, 2006
|
|
Dean Bertoncelj |
|
tnx... I will post one more.. but this time no quick answer.... let more ppl try :o)
February 22, 2006
|
|
Log in to respond or ask your own question.
|