BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: New Answers

Photography Question 

James E. McKinney
 

Focusing trick


I read somewhere that you can zoom in on a subject, focus manually, zoom back out, snap the picture and the subject will still be in sharp focus. Is this true and if it is can you use autofocus the same way? I am having problems obtaining sharp focus with my 10D even with a tripod.
Thanks for any help.
James


To love this question, log in above
November 10, 2004

 

Jon Close
  It was true for most zoom zoom lenses in the manual focus era. They were designed to be parfocal so that changing the zoom setting did not change the point of focus.

However, it's very difficult to incorporate that design with autofocus, so almost all autofocus zooms are vari-focal: changing the zoom setting changes the focus. Best results are acheived by zooming to the desired focal length setting first, then focus and take the photo without changing the zoom.

Focus-lock and recompose can also introduce focusing error, especially when the subject is very close. Using the wide area AF sensor closest to your subject is more accurate than using center focus then recomposing and putting the subject off center.

Autofocus algorithms generally quit when focus is within the maximum apeture depth of field. (The EOS 1v and 3 film SLRs and EOS 1-series DSLRs have high precision AF that focuses w/in 1/3 DoF) If there is enough light and your eyesight is good enough you may (or may not) get more precise focus manually.

I've read many digital users (on other forums) complain of inherent "backfocus" problems with the Canon and Nikon DSLRs and they send them off to the service centers for recalibration. Personally, I think the cameras are functioning as designed (AF to w/in the DoF) and they are being hypercritical by looking at their images on a monitor at 100%. Per the very helpful Canon brochure, Getting The Most
From Your EOS-1 Class Digital SLR
,
"Understand that image magnification affects perceived sharpness:
When viewing images at 100% magnification, the actual image size can be as large as 4 x 6 FEET depending on the resolution of the camera. If your images are regularly printed at 8.5" x 11" or less, the equivalent magnification with EOS-1D Mark II would be approximately 33%, or 25% with an EOS-1Ds. Try printing your images to evaluate sharpness." Also see the section on applying in-camera sharpening or using an editor like Photoshop's Unsharp Mask, to counter the softening by the anti-alias filter.



To love this comment, log in above
November 10, 2004

 
This old forum is now archived. Use improved Forum here

Report this Thread